[PFS Cross-post]
Hans-Hermann Hoppe’s writing is rigorous and also remarkably learned. He draws on a wealth of sources and thinkers—philosophers, economists, sociologists, historians, anthropologists—across many fields, and he returns to some of them again and again. In this he stands in the tradition of the thinkers we Austro-libertarians rely on most, such as Mises, Rothbard, and Hayek, none of whom were narrow specialists.
Hoppe has remarked on this himself. He calls Mises and Rothbard “the twentieth century’s two greatest—though much neglected—economists and social philosophers.” 1 The Austrian School itself, he notes, “ranks among the most outstanding of the many intellectual and artistic traditions originating in pre-World War I Austria,” a place and time whose “list of great names” is “seemingly endless.” 2 Rothbard, Hoppe says, “was not and did not want to be a mere economist-economist. He was also a great philosopher, sociologist, and historian, and as such became the creator of a grand, integrated intellectual system.” 3 And: “Murray had a huge library, had read and digested an enormous amount of literature and was consequently a humble man.” He was skeptical of “originality” claims, which “are made most frequently by people with tiny libraries and little reading,” and “on almost any conceivable subject, he was prepared, off the top of his head, to provide you with an extensive bibliography.” 4 Even Hayek, though Hoppe is “not a Hayekian,” 5 earns his praise as “one of the twentieth century’s outstanding intellectuals writing in the social sciences,” owing to his “wide-ranging interdisciplinary oeuvre, which contains a treasure trove of keen insights into many issues.” 6 For Hoppe, this goes with rationalism itself: “the rationalist attitude is one of intellectual humility and respect for the history of thought.” 7
Hoppe works in the same vein, and says so. The studies collected in Democracy: The God That Failed, he writes, are “everything a good positivist claims one cannot and shall not be: interdisciplinary, theoretically oriented, and dealing with both positive-empirical and normative questions.” 8 The Mises Institute lectures published as Economy, Society, and History were meant to be “a wide-ranging, interdisciplinary intellectual endeavor, touching upon questions of philosophy, economics, anthropology, sociology, and history.” 9 As Lew Rockwell put it, “Like Murray, Hans is a scholar of near universal interests. He is fully at home in anthropology and sociology, as well as global history, economics, and philosophy.” 10 For a taste of Hoppe’s reading, see his “Anarcho-Capitalism: An Annotated Bibliography.” Besides Rothbard and the Austro-libertarians, it covers alternative approaches, precursors, and “congenial writings” by the likes of Robert Nisbet, Bertrand de Jouvenel, and Franz Oppenheimer. 11
Over the years I’ve learned a great deal from many of these thinkers myself. I’ve cited some of them in my own work, and many of their books are in my library. So I recently gave Claude, Anthropic’s AI, seven of Hoppe’s books: A Theory of Socialism and Capitalism (TSC), Economic Science and the Austrian Method (ESAM), The Economics and Ethics of Private Property (EEPP), Democracy: The God That Failed (DGF), The Great Fiction: Property, Economy, Society, and the Politics of Decline (TGF), A Short History of Man: Progress and Decline, and Economy, Society, and History (ESH). I asked it to identify the main thinkers Hoppe relies on and cites positively and repeatedly, and to summarize what he typically cites each one for. I started with the realist and rationalist philosophers behind, for example, the epistemology and ethics of chapters 6 and 7 of TSC. Then I asked about Alasdair MacIntyre, and then about Robert Nisbet and other sociologists like him. Here is what it came up with. 12 (Sadly, because of copyright fascism, most of these works are not legally available online.) 13
1. The Philosophers
These are the philosophers Hoppe cites most often and most approvingly, roughly in order of how much he leans on them. Strictly speaking, most of them are rationalists or anti-empiricists rather than realists. Blanshard leaned idealist, and the Erlangen constructivists, Apel and Habermas, and Kant aren’t realists either. The real realists in the group are Henry Veatch, John Wild, and Andrew van Melsen.
- Hoppe, The Economics and Ethics of Private Property, Preface to the First Edition. [↩]
- Hoppe, Democracy: The God That Failed, Introduction, pp. xii, xxii. [↩]
- Hoppe, “The In-Depth Interview,” in The Great Fiction: Property, Economy, Society, and the Politics of Decline, 2d ed., ch. 31, p. 558. [↩]
- Hoppe, “Coming of Age with Murray,” in The Great Fiction, ch. 22, pp. 397–98. [↩]
- See Hoppe on Hayek; Hoppe, PFP101 | Hans-Hermann Hoppe, The Hayek Myth (PFS 2012); “The Hayek Myth” (PFS 2012); Hoppe, F.A. Hayek on Government and Social Evolution: A Critique (Vol. 7 Num. 1) (also in The Great Fiction); Hoppe, Why Mises (and not Hayek)?; Walter Block, “Hayek’s Road to Serfdom”; Kinsella, Don’t tell me to read Hayek; Kinsella, Hayek on Intellectual Property. [↩]
- Hoppe, “The Libertarian Quest for a Grand Historical Narrative,” Mises Wire (Nov. 5, 2018), reprinted in The Great Fiction, ch. 25, p. 471. [↩]
- Hoppe, “The Western State as a Paradigm: Learning from History,” in The Great Fiction, p. 466. [↩]
- Hoppe, Democracy: The God That Failed, Introduction, p. xxiii. [↩]
- Hoppe, Economy, Society, and History, Preface. [↩]
- Llewellyn H. Rockwell, Jr., Foreword to Hoppe, A Short History of Man: Progress and Decline, p. 11. [↩]
- Hans-Hermann Hoppe, “Anarcho-Capitalism: An Annotated Bibliography,” LewRockwell.com (Dec. 31, 2001). [↩]
- The mention counts it worked from are rough and somewhat inflated, since several of Hoppe’s methodological essays, such as “On Praxeology and the Praxeological Foundation of Epistemology” and “In Defense of Extreme Rationalism,” are reprinted across ESAM, EEPP, and TGF. [↩]
- See Kinsella, How long copyright terms make art disappear, C4SIF Blog (July 6, 2013). [↩]












